Education Equity News

‘Protect the values we hold dear’: A closer look inside the Ed Meek, Ole Miss race controversy

'Protect the values we hold dear': A closer look inside the Ed Meek, Ole Miss race controversy

Devna Bose, The Every day Mississippian

Sophomore Seyna Clark instantly addresses Chancellor Jeffrey Vitter throughout an open discussion board for college kids following an inappropriate submit made by Ed Meek on his Fb web page that prompted a mass backlash.

Erin Pennington has a method with phrases.

In any case, she began learning to be knowledgeable communicator two years in the past when she discovered the fundamentals of how shortly information and knowledge is disseminated in the present age of social media. Different programs taught her how journalists use social media as a reporting software and the way to amplify tales to spice up their attain and influence. This yr, she’s studying about the ethics of social media in public relations, together with the significance of exercising logic when representing each a private model and that of a corporation.

But on September 19, Pennington, a junior broadcast journalism main at the College of Mississippi’s faculty of journalism and president of the scholar chapter of the Nationwide Affiliation of Black Journalists, might solely muster one phrase when describing to her mom a Fb submit going round social media.

“Racist,” she texted with a screenshot of the submit, including an eye fixed roll emoji for impact.

The submit was written by Ed Meek, a public-relations business veteran with deep ties to the college and Oxford and patron of the journalism faculty Pennington attends.

Meek’s submit, which shortly unfold throughout Mississippians’ social media channels and went viral throughout the net quickly after, included pictures of two African American ladies on the Sq. after the Ole Miss-Alabama soccer recreation.  

“I hesitated until now to publish these pictures but I think it important that our community see what the camera is seeing at 2 a.m. after a ballgame… Enough, Oxford and Ole Miss leaders, get on top of this before it is too late. A 3 percent decline in enrollment is nothing compared to what we will see if this continues, and real estate values will plummet as will tax revenue. We all share in the responsibility to protect the values we hold dear that have made Oxford and Ole Miss known nationally,” Meek wrote on his Fb web page.

It’s not solely clear what the “this” is Meek believes is the supply of the drawback. However nobody actually is aware of why enrollment at the faculty is on the decline. In the meantime, the Oxford actual property market continues to be experiencing speedy progress, notably amongst retirees, so it’s unlikely the metropolis has seen a big drop in property values. However no matter Meek meant, regardless of the reality that the majority of the tons of of revelers that night time dressed of their gameday best have been white, he positioned the blame for issues of Ole Miss and Oxford squarely at the ft of two of the few black ladies out on the Sq..

By no means Miss a Beat. Signal Up for our Every day Publication.

Given the college’s historical past with race relations, the uproar over the submit was loud and the response from Ole Miss officers comparatively swift.

Jeffrey Vitter, the college’s chancellor, posted a public condemnation of what he referred to as an “unjustified racial overtone that is highly offensive” in the publish. Ole Miss and Meek Faculty alumni expressed disgust on their social networks. Reporters for nationwide information retailers set to work and produced tales for Essence, the New York Occasions, Nationwide Public Radio, The Root and different retailers.

Ed Meek a provided these pictures and pitched a narrative about prostitution in Oxford to a information outlet he based. When the editors refused to write down the story he needed revealed, Meek wrote this on Fb. The submit, which he later deleted, was extensively criticized as racist and sexist.

“I relinquish being over-sexualized, scapegoated and invalidated by anyone. I deserve to feel secure in my skin on this campus and in this town just as my counterparts do and I will continue to carry on as such,” considered one of the ladies pictured in Meek’s submit, wrote in a searing column revealed in the Every day Mississippian, the student-run newspaper.

(Editor’s word: Although the names of the ladies pictured in Meek’s publish have been revealed on-line, Mississippi At this time is declining to incorporate their names on this story.)

Dealing with fierce and mounting public criticism, Meek deleted the publish 5 hours after he first hit publish and issued an apology. After a collection of journalism school conferences, Meek requested that his identify be faraway from the journalism faculty. That request required motion from the Establishments of Larger Studying, which oversees the state-supported schools and universities, which unanimously voted on October 18 to grant the request and strip Meek’s identify from the constructing.

“I thought to myself, ‘Wow, does he think that of all of us?,” Pennington stated. “Even the black journalism students attending the school named after him?’”

A onerous line in the sand

Because it seems, Meek’s submit was a a lot toned down model of what he thought and needed the world to see.

Share Your Information Tip With Us

Mississippi At this time obtained audio from a September 20 assembly the place the journalism school mentioned the state of affairs and gave an accounting of the sequence of occasions previous Meek’s publish and what adopted in the days instantly after the controversy erupted.

Subsequent conversations with college students and school members concerned in discussions with college officers confirmed the particulars included on the recording.

On September 16, the morning after the Ole Miss-Alabama soccer recreation, Meek referred to as Rachel West, the chief government officer of HottyToddy.com, a information web site based mostly in Oxford that Meek based in 2012, with a information tip and provided to ship alongside a pair of pictures to run with the story.

Meek, who was touring the weekend of the Ole Miss-Alabama recreation, didn’t take the pictures of the ladies, however acquired them from an acquaintance in Oxford. The story concept Meek handed alongside was that prostitution and fights have been hurting Oxford’s character and long-term monetary viability, implying that the ladies in the pictures have been intercourse staff.

On the school assembly recording, West, who can also be a journalism professor, might be heard saying, referring to Meek: “He called me Sunday and said there is a problem with potential crime and fighting in Oxford … He has been on me since Sunday (September 16) to put this on Hotty Toddy, and I refused to do it.”

HottyToddy.com’s editor-in-chief, Anna Grace Usery, clarified: “The email (from Meek) referenced that there were these girls who were turning tricks,” a slang time period for prostitution, “and he attached these two photos in his email. I, of course, looked at police records to see if, by any chance, there were any prostitution arrests, and there were not. So I drew a hard line in the sand.”

West, the CEO, advised the school: “Ladies and gentlemen, this post was premeditated. I want you all to understand my observation is the following: That this was not a knee-jerk reaction. This was intended, and had been discussed, a while – well, 72 hours at least. And I told him not to do it, and I told him I certainly wasn’t going to be associated with any format that did it.”

‘Black problem in Oxford’

Alexis T. Rhoden | The Every day Mississippian

The Meek Faculty of Journalism and New Media held a city corridor earlier this semester to permit the college group to voice its opinions relating to Ed Meek’s controversial Fb publish.

Meek didn’t return calls or emails to be interviewed for this story, and has made no public statements about the incident since he apologized on Sept. 22.

However with an entire accounting of conversations that led to Meek’s choice to tug the set off on the Fb submit, the school on September 21 unanimously voted to ask Meek to take away his identify from the journalism faculty. He complied, launching an expedited course of inside school and administrative committees at the college to maneuver the request alongside.

Will Norton, the dean of the journalism faculty and a longtime good friend of Meek’s, initially appeared in a video the place he’s flanked by the faculty’s school, together with two black school members at his aspect. “In every class we teach, we ask our faculty to make a statement that the school of journalism and new media is committed to diversity in the classroom,” Norton stated in the video.

“This includes helping our students to develop a sensitivity to language and images that may create an appearance of or contain actual bias. It’s a foundational principle of good journalism. It’s our responsibility. We take it very seriously.”

In an interview with Mississippi Right now, Norton, the dean of the journalism faculty since 2009, described the internal turmoil of balancing his duty to the college students underneath his care and his loyalty to an expensive a good friend. (Disclosure: Norton is a founding and lively Mississippi At present board member and donor.)

“I wanted to hear what the faculty was thinking. There was a lot of hurt and a lot of anger. You had to have a meeting like that so the next meeting could be more rational,” Norton stated. “This is somebody I really admire and really respect. And I have faculty who were hurt by this person, and students who were hurt by the big mistake.”

Seyna Clark, a sophomore journalism main, was amongst them.

“When I first read Ed Meek’s post, I didn’t read that there was a crime problem in Oxford, but rather a black problem in Oxford,” Clark advised Mississippi At present. “To me, it seems as if he is implying that black people are out of control and that we were the problem.”  

Devna Bose, The Every day Mississippian

Former Black Scholar Union President Jarvis Benson embraces certainly one of the ladies focused in Ed Meek’s controversial Fb submit.

A little after 24 hours after Meek posted on Fb, Clark and dozens of her fellow college students gathered at a journalism school-sponsored discussion board to debate the incident. That night, emotions of terror and disrespect have been shared by black college students. College students opened up about the racial local weather on campus, and the way college life for college kids of shade is far totally different from life for white college students.

Stated Clark: “It’s uncomfortable as a Black Muslim woman to go to a school that takes pride in calling themselves the Rebels or Ole Miss. Let’s not pretend to act like we don’t know the meanings behind these symbols and names.”

Ole Miss in context

AP

U.S. marshals escort James Meredith, middle with briefcase, to the College of Mississippi campus on Oct. 2, 1962. Meredith, was the first black scholar to attend the College of Mississippi.

Meek’s personal affiliation with College of Mississippi began with its most well-known racial drama.

In 1962, as federal troops fought the crowd of white Mississippians indignant a few black Air Pressure veteran named James Meredith enrolling in the college, Meek, then a younger scholar photographer, documented the riot that left two individuals lifeless on campus.

In the weeks that adopted, Meek took a number of now iconic pictures of Meredith. Meek additionally turned a “big man on campus as Campus Cutie Editor,” which concerned taking risque photographs of white coeds, he wrote for a HottyToddy.com column revealed in January 2018.

In the years that adopted Ole Miss’s integration, Meek turned the public relations director for the college, which, in an ironic twist, concerned repairing the picture of the college that his photojournalism was integral to forging in the wake of the 1962 riot.

As the years wore on, Meek, a self-proclaimed “Mississippi redneck from Charleston,” frequently spoke of the formative qualities of that point.

“I came to Ole Miss from Charleston,” Meek stated in an interview with Mississippi Public Broadcasting in 2016. “I introduced with me lots of the prejudices we all had at the moment. I denied that for a few years. It wasn’t politically sensible to take action, and I admit it now.

“All of us had certain thoughts. It was a different era. It was the era of Miss Americas, the era of fun and festivities. And then this serious event comes along and changes the course of history for me as I spent the rest of my career dealing with these issues and trying to reshape the image of the University of Mississippi.”

The Oxford of Meek’s coming of age is a distant reminiscence of at the moment’s Oxford. When he was an undergraduate at the College of Mississippi in 1960, car visitors on the sleepy Sq. flowed two methods. Right now, police shut parts of the Sq.’s roadways to accommodate the shoulder-to-shoulder, typically well-stewed, foot visitors.

Oxford had 5,283 residents in 1960. The city’s inhabitants at the most up-to-date counting approaches 25,000. The College of Mississippi had simply over four,000 college students in 1960; as we speak it’s house to virtually 24,000, though that quantity, as Meek identified, is declining.

In the 1960s, the city’s few African American residents weren’t allowed in outlets, bars or eating places on the Sq.. Older African American Oxonians keep in mind that some companies wouldn’t even permit black individuals to face beneath their awnings throughout rainstorms.

Since 1962, the campus has repeatedly been a flashpoint for racial rigidity in addition to sexual harassment of girls and insensitivity towards LGBTQ individuals, every of them drawing widespread media protection.

The Lyceum on the College of Mississippi campus

In 2015, members of the Ku Klux Klan visited campus  to protest a student-led initiative to get the faculty to cease flying the state flag, which is the final in nation containing the Accomplice battle emblem. In 2014, two white college students positioned noose and an previous Georgia state flag displaying the Accomplice battle emblem on the Meredith statue.

When President Barack Obama was re-elected in 2012, a younger white man burned an Obama/Biden marketing campaign signal as a number of different white males appeared on. That picture, too, circulated far and extensive as did false rumors that a race riot was underway on the campus.  

Ole Miss can also be pockmarked with Accomplice image, together with a towering monument that’s one among the first issues guests see once they arrive on the rolling campus. A number of buildings on campus are named after Accomplice sympathizers. The college is residence to a Accomplice cemetery, the place heritage teams meet yearly to commemorate the Misplaced Trigger. Up till 2016, the college’s marching band referred to as “The Pride of the South” routinely performed the music “Dixie,” the Accomplice Military’s battle cry.

Regardless of the faculty ridding itself of its Colonel Reb mascot in 2003, the nickname for its athletic groups stays the “Rebels,” an homage to the Accomplice troopers in the Civil Conflict, which the state of Mississippi joined to protect slavery. And even the faculty’s nickname harks again to how slaves addressed plantation mistresses: Ol’ Miss.

Six extra plaques unveiled to offer context to Ole Miss’ historical past

In March 2018, the college unveiled six markers contextualizing its historical past.

Plaques for Barnard Observatory, Lamar Corridor, Longstreet Corridor and George Corridor have been launched, as was a marker recognizing the college’s enslaved laborers in the development of Barnard Observatory, the Previous Chapel (now Croft), the Lyceum and Hilgard Reduce.

One other plaque to be positioned at the stained-glass Tiffany home windows in Ventress Corridor acknowledges the College Greys, a Civil Conflict firm of primarily college college students that suffered 100 % casualties – killed, wounded or captured.

The presentation adopted months of research by the Chancellor’s Advisory Committee on Historical past and Context.

However, every racist episode at the college that creeps into the public eye salts previous wounds for the campus’s black group.

“We constantly have to reassure our family that it’s OK and pretend like it’s safe,” Clark stated. “It’s uncomfortable going to classes and being one of the only black student in class. It’s traumatizing walking down hallways or sitting in the library and seeing white students wear Confederate flags or Colonel Reb on their hats and T-shirts and Trump ‘Make America Great’ stickers on their laptops. They’re sending a real clear message.”

A highly effective assertion

For Meek, an irony of the second lies in his early advocacy for what he referred to as new media. When most individuals nonetheless received most of their information from print newspapers and tv, new media was a time period coined in the aughts to explain information created in digital areas together with the web and social media – the very instruments that enabled tens of millions of individuals to see, and be horrified by, his on-line musings in actual time.

In reality, the Ole Miss journalism faculty in all probability wouldn’t exist if not for Meek’s shut involvement. In 2008, he donated $5.three million to create the Meek Faculty of Journalism and New Media. The latter a part of the faculty’s identify was nicely thought out — journalism college students in the age of the web and social media ought to refine the expertise essential to survive in an business shifting quickly towards the Net, Meek and faculty officers reasoned at the time.

For years, Meek preached to anybody who would pay attention the worth of educating digital expertise so college students might thrive in a altering business. He took the mission so significantly that he based the information web site HottyToddy.com, the place college students might sharpen their expertise.

“He wanted this (HottyToddy.com) to be a platform for the students to use and learn from,” Kate Wallace, Meek’s granddaughter and the website’s former managing editor, stated in 2014.

Google Maps

The location of the Meek Faculty of Journalism on the campus of the College of Mississippi.

What comes subsequent for Mississippi’s solely journalism faculty, now that Meek’s identify is formally faraway from it, is just not clear.

Whereas general enrollment at four-year faculties is on the decline, fewer African People are selecting the state’s flagship establishment and the faculty of journalism.

A 2016-2017 accreditation report states African American made up 9.four % of enrollment throughout the 2015-2016 faculty yr in contrast the college’s African American enrollment of 13.5 %.

Each numbers have been a decline from the earlier yr’s black enrollment of 10.eight % and 14.four %, for the journalism faculty and college as an entire, respectively –– a development that the journalism faculty’s variety committee met about simply two days earlier than Meek’s Sept. 19 Fb submit.

“A strong appeal to minorities is the relatively low out-of-state tuition rate. A negative point for recruiting students is parents of potential students recall the university’s violent civil rights history in the 1960s,” members of the accreditation staff wrote on the report.

“However, observations have shown that black middle-class parents have begun to recognize that the Ole Miss of the past is not the Ole Miss of today. For example, the university was in the news nationally for eliminating the song “Dixie” from soccer video games. This can be a place of contradictions for some: a statue of a Accomplice soldier is just a brief distance on campus from the statue commemorating James Meredith.”

One concept to show that Ole Miss stays welcoming to college students of shade is gaining steam.

Greater than 100 school members on campus, together with a number of journalism school members, signed a petition to rename the faculty for Ida B. Wells-Barnett, who was born into slavery in close by Holly Springs and have become a pioneer of investigative and knowledge journalism by means of dogged reporting of lynchings in the South. Wells-Barnett’s nice granddaughter, Michelle Duster, has publicly supported the suggestion.

MacArthur Basis

Nikole Hannah-Jones, a New York Occasions Journal reporter and co-founder of the Ida B. Wells Society for Investigative Journalism

Nikole Hannah-Jones, an investigative reporter with New York Occasions Journal and co-founder of the Ida B. Wells Society for Investigative Journalism, which goals to develop the ranks of journalists of colour in newsrooms, stated renaming the faculty for Wells-Barnett would ship a strong message.

“Let’s remember, outside of her reporting on lynching and outside of her being an innovator in the field of investigative journalism and data reporting, she helped to co-found the NAACP. She was a suffragist. She did this at a time when black people were losing their rights, when Reconstruction was coming to an end. This woman persevered and fearlessly told the story black people dying through extrajudicial violence,” Hannah-Jones, who has household ties to Greenwood, advised Mississippi At this time.  

“At a place like Ole Miss, to have one of the most prominent buildings named after a black woman would say a lot about where that university and the state of Mississippi is, and can be, today.”

R.L. Nave contributed reporting.